Conscientious objection and healthcare in the UK: why tribunals are not the answer

J Med Ethics 2016;42:69-72
Author: Christopher Cowley
“A recent issue of the journal Bioethics discussed whether conscientious objectors within the healthcare context should be required to give their reasons to a specially convened tribunal, who would have the power to reject the objection. This is modeled on the context of military conscription. Advocates for such a tribunal offer two different justifications, one based on determining the genuineness of the applicant’s beliefs, the other based on determining their reasonableness. I limit my discussion to a doctor’s objection to abortion in the UK, and argue against both justifications…”
Find abstract and links to commentaries in reply here.